|











| |
Sometimes Soccer Wins
With a Tie
I'm glad to see
that after four seasons, MLS has decided to do away
with the largely unpopular "shootout" as their unique way of
deciding tied
regular season games. Its not that I've got a problem with the shootout as a
tiebreaker. On the contrary, when ties NEED to be broken its a more
game-realistic way of doing so than penalty kicks. I just don't see why
non-tournament games can't finish tied.
All over the world, ties are part and parcel of the
game of soccer. The
only time that penalty shootouts become a factor are in knockout
competitions, when time constraints and travel concerns demand that a winner
be determined on the day.
But in the regular season, when games finish all
square, that's it.
Game over. One point each. Well done everyone.
In the US, baseball and basketball don't allow tied
games, but now MLS
has come into line with the NFL and the NHL in accepting ties after an
additional overtime period. And I'm sure that soccer fans throughout the
country will see the MLS in a more favorable light and as a more legitimate
competition as a result.
The same cannot be said of boys' high school soccer.
The National
Federation of State High School Associations, of which the Iowa High School
Athletic Association (IHSAA) is part, mandates that penalty kicks be used to
determine the winner of regular season games that are tied after two
40-minute halves, and two 10-minute sudden victory, overtime periods.
I don't understand this need to crown an artificial
winner if two
teams, having battled honors-even for 100 minutes, cannot be separated by
conventional scoring methods. Let the score stand. If the game does not have
to have a winner, let the teams share the spoils.
So, for those people at Saturday's Trojan Classic
boys high school
soccer tournament, philosophically, this is where I was coming from after
City High's two 1-1 ties in the first and third games of the day.
On a somewhat related topic, the professional game
appears to be
benefiting from an incredible youth movement right now. The MLS
season is
only two weekends old but already talented youngsters including Bobby Convey
(16), and Chris Albright (17) of D.C. United, and DaMarcus Beasley (17) of
the Chicago Fire, have seen action.
Overseas, both Liverpool and Leeds United of the
English Premier
League, have reportedly bid $2.5 million for the services of 15 year old
Cherno Samba, a striker with 2nd Division London club, Millwall.
It's hard to imagine that these players are young
enough to still be
playing high school soccer. I wonder what they're like at taking penalties?
From the Iowa City Press Citizen, April 3, 2000
Submitted By: Ian Parratt
- Coaching Director, Iowa City Alliance Soccer Club
|